We fell in love with The Old Mill after our first visit back in 2018 and wasted no time booking our date because we knew we had found the PERFECT place to say "I Do". From the lush secluded meadow, to the babbling creek and ivy covered stonework, we were beyond excited for the beauty this venue packs into such a small footprint. The photo opportunities are endless!! We spent the next 2 years planning our dream wedding, which went surprisingly smooth (for someone as unorganized as myself). Don, Taylor and the rest of the Conner Catering team made the whole process unbelievably easy and enjoyable, and were available at the drop of a hat for any questions (which was a lifesaver, because we had a ton of questions!) When covid hit, I think we felt every emotion we could feel, and really didn't know what to do. Don and Taylor did an amazing job keeping us in the loop with all the state and federal regulations and changes, and helped us calm down and plan a dream wedding in these uncertain ti... Read moremes. At a time when the wedding industry was turned on it's head, we never once felt like the Conner Catering team were unprepared for the challenges thrown at them! When our big day came we were beyond blessed with the most beautiful fall day and in the end were able to still have our dream wedding at our dream venue, The Old Mill! THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU, amazing experience, amazing people and amazing venue!

Due to covid, our entire wedding changed over the course of a few months. The venue was extremely flexible and incredibly helpful with keeping up with health guidelines. They went from being our reception venue (indoors) to being our ceremony and reception space (entirely outdoors). Not only is the staff wonderful, but the site is exceptionally gorgeous. Everyone complimented how beautiful the scenery was and our photos turned out absolutely amazing. The only downside to this venue for those who are looking for a late night party is that Rose Valley is a residential area that has very strict alcohol and music policies. If you are looking for a late night party reception, this is not the spot for you. I would 100% recommend this space to all of my friends. It was perfect.

The Old Mill and the Conner Catering Team were a dream to work with. When we originally booked with them two years prior, we had anticipated a larger wedding with nearly 250 guest. As COVID hit, they did everything in their power and within safety to ensure we were still able to have our special day. Although we cut our guest list back, made multiple changes to ensure our guests were safe, the team at the Old Mill were very responsive, flexible and quick to make sure we could have the wedding we dreamed of. The day of events went beautifully and smoothly, and the food was amazing! Its a night I will never forget. Leading up to the big day, we did have several meetings with Don, who walked us through all our options and costs to ensure our budget was met. I do wish they had an online payment option, just as we live farther away and I always worry mailing checks- but at the end of the day it was no issue and any worry I had was answered right away with reassure or confirmation of b... Read moreeing received! We also were able to stock the bar ourselves, which I personally really liked as we had exactly what we wanted available. I highly recommend the Old Mill to anyone looking for a wedding venue. The staff were some of the nicest people I have met during a wedding, and they put up with my very loud, enthusiastic family with grace and professionalism. Not to mention the venue itself is nothing short of stunning! Thank you again to the Old Mill and Conner Catering!

The Old Mill is a breathtaking venue! From the stone courtyard covered in ivy to the field right next to the stream this location and company was everything we hoped it would be and more. Conner Catering is a phenomenal company. Donald was always able to hop on a call with us or schedule a meeting if we needed to talk. Having a wedding in the middle of a pandemic is more than stressful but they took as much pressure and stress off of us as they could and on our wedding day it truly did not feel like we were in the middle of a pandemic! At the Old Mill you don't get a folder filled with different wedding packages, instead Donald tells you to run free with your wedding dreams and they will make it happen! We had a mishap with our wedding cake and it was completely ruined when it arrived at the venue and Donald took it upon himself to call every local bakery to find us a new cake. When he couldn't find one he himself ran out to Giant and bought a bunch of cakes to facet a new one for us! ... Read moreI didn't even know it wasn't our cake until my husband told me! And it was more beautiful than our original. My favorite part was that we could build our wedding and what we wanted it to look like. This truly was an amazing experience and we have already suggested this venue to a few of our engaged friends!

My husband and I got married this August (2020) at the Old Mill. I couldn't say enough how amazing our day was. The venue itself is absolutely gorgeous, and has a great alternate plan for inclement weather (the pavilion is GORGEOUS!). The food is just AMAZING -- I am vegan but my husband is not, so we had a mixture. Vegans and non vegans alike said all of the food was amazing! They even had vegan snacks waiting for me in the bridal suite. They definitely make their couples feel special!! The service staff was incredibly friendly and professional! They allow you to supply your own alcohol which helps you save some money too! We communicated mostly with Donald and Taylor. Donald is very detail-oriented and efficient - he made sure everything went smoothly and was great about talking through our options when we had to rework our original 130-guest wedding plan due to the pandemic. Taylor is super responsive and friendly -- I emailed her millions of questions and she was always so great an... Read mored informative in her responses! Conner Catering put extensive care and effort into making our event safe amidst the pandemic. Our event was held completely outdoors aside from the restrooms (guests had to wear face coverings to go inside for the bathroom), masks and hand sanitizer were stationed throughout, and ceremony and reception seating was spaced at least 6 feet apart. We reduced our guest count to less than 50 people, and Conner was so flexible with all of our changes. I would not change a thing about our wedding experience, and we are so grateful to Conner Catering and the Old Mill for making our day so special!

Conner Catering provided a 5 star experience for my daughter’s wedding ceremony & reception. The staff is professional, courteous, and attentive ... providing a top notch experience for all. The food was exceptional too!! The bride & groom had a wedding to cherish for years to come!!

I've been fortunate enough to attend a couple weddings here and have fallen in love with its vaulted ceilings, wooded outdoor area, and old stone. My photos don't do it justice, but the caterer did a great job integrating their setup and taking advantage of the natural beauty of the venue. I can't wait to see the progressional photos!

The Old Mill and Conner Catering did an incredible job making our wedding day so special and memorable. After 2 date changes in 2020, they worked so hard to help us have the wedding we always wanted- from extra tents and outdoor dinner, safety protocols, professionalism, and a number of meetings, we had the best day. The Old Mill is a beautiful space and we can't say enough good things about Conner Catering's team and staff. Recommend 10/10 !

Words truly can not express our gratitude for the service that Don, Taylor, and their team provided for our special day. They exhibited extreme professionalism throughout the entire planning process, and the day of the wedding, to make this the best day of our lives. From answering my million questions to providing great ideas while planning, their team was unmatched...they almost treated us like their own family members. People were RAVING to us about the food and the venue and how beautiful everything was. Not only that but everything was PERFECTLY on time. We had so much time to dance and have fun :). I am so thankful we chose Conner Catering and The Old Mill for our wedding day. We will never forget this day or Don and his team.

I cannot say enough good things about The Old Mill. Without a doubt, this was one of the best choice we made. During the entire process, Don and Taylor of Conner Catering were amazing. When we first toured the Old Mill and met with Don, he was very helpful. My family has very little experience planning weddings, so he helped guide us. After we booked, Taylor and Don were great with details and giving us suggestions. Without their expertise, the wedding would not have gone as well as it did. The day of the wedding, things got a little messed up because 95 was shut down-- delaying the wedding party 1.5 hours. Don was very flexible and made sure everything was okay to extend an hour. The food was AMAZING. We received so many compliments about the food. During the process, we were worried about staying under budget for food, but still having a tasty meal. Don was very aware of our budget and made sure we got the best possible meal. Everything is very customizable, so you do not sacri... Read morefice quality at all. Without a doubt, this was the best choice we made and are so grateful to Conner Catering and the Old Mill! Amazing food and an amazing team! The venue photographs beautifully and is magical. Great indoor space and amazing outdoor space. Book this place!

Where to even start?!? The Old Mill and Conner Catering are spectacular. From the moment we booked to the day of the wedding, Donald, Taylor and the rest of the team went above and beyond for us. For our wedding, we requested a family style dinner. Working hand in hand with Donald and his team, we created a stellar menu for our 150+ guests. Their execution and thoroughness were second to none. Our guests enjoyed every bite of food, from start to finish. They are still talking about how delicious everything was! The waitstaff were attentive, polite and so friendly! The Old Mill served as the absolute perfect backdrop for our special day with Conner Catering. We simply cannot recommend it enough!

Most beautiful wedding venue in Pennsylvania, possibly in the United States!

it was an amazing experience, we find this venue at the last minute but think God they were able to have us on our special day without any change of our weeding date, everything was great, foods sevice, the team was amazing, servial and wonderful, we definitely recommend it to other people

I cannot say enough of how much we loved getting married at The Old Mill. Donald was kind and fun to work with and unfortunately we started to hit some problems after Covid rules started to affect the wedding. Don and his team were able to make everything work and as things got closer we had to move things outside and only have 25 people inside when the reception was supposed to be all inside. He ordered tents to put up outside and was able to make so many requests work such as the courtyard free for dancing. Unfortunately there were added costs. We had no idea we were going to be charged for the tent because we needed to move everything outside last minute and the cost was going to have a huge impact on our budget. We were not notified we were supposed to pay and thought they were paying for it. We had a tent we could have used but it was not well communicated to us until we received a bill two weeks before the wedding because these changes were so last minute. Thankfully Don hand... Read moreled the situation Kindly and we were able to move forward. Communication and understanding was a huge issue. We were told we would have to pay extra to be under 100 guests and we had counted that towards our budget, an extra $1500. All the notes for costs are handwritten and nothing concrete that we could fight when at the final week were charged an extra $30 per person for meals from our original $102.50 charge agreed upon. It was never advertised we would be charged so much more, especially last minute. This was before the 18% gratuity charge ad 6 % taxes extra on top of everything we also had budgeted for. We trusted his word and what he had written, but because we had no contract for these prices he was able to charge us whatever he decided in the end. We could have understood some extra fees with Covid, but not an extra $30 per person for food that we had not agreed to pay. Overall we had to pay $3000 instead of $1500 that we had agreed on. If we also had to pay for the tent it would have been $2700 extra for everything that we hadn't agreed to pay. We truly recommend this place, but only if you can get the invoiced contract in writing and I am not sure they will do that. We tried to get written prices, but even those were not entirely accurate it seems. It was a terrible situation and if our parents hadn't been so understanding we would have lost all our money invested and no wedding the week before the wedding. The rehearsal we found hornets nests in the lodge and he had them all removed and fixed the very next day which was amazing! Even not knowing where we would get married (due to a flash flood the night before) he was extremely flexible and great with helping us create back up plans where we would get married. The day of Don and his team were impeccable with making everything work and any issues that arose. They also were incredible with following state guidelines, but never letting it negatively impact the wedding. Masks and social distancing outside, grouping of households at tables, and minimum 25 people inside. Most stayed outside because of the beautiful night. We believe that without all the positivity and efforts made by The Old Mill we might not have gotten married due to Covid restrictions. We had our dream wedding. it was everything we could have asked for and more. We would consider renewing our vows there as long as we could get costs in writing. The courtyard is a dream, like stepping through to a place of magic. The lodge and inside is rustic and matched our modern viking themed wedding perfectly! We look back on the day with no regrets and complete awe at how fortunate we were to have such a great team willing to put aside any issues and make it incredible for us and our entire family. I close my eyes and I still feel myself there, spinning around the dance floor with my husband!