It has taken us a week to decide whether or not we wanted to write this review. Last Friday, June 26, 2020, we were originally scheduled to be married at The Old Mill. As everyone is aware, the final PA counties went green on the 26th. Being faced with making a decision weeks in advance of that, we felt it best to cancel as we wanted to protect our family and friends and the Old Mill had limited dates available (unless we wanted to postpone for a significant amount of time) and we had selected this venue specifically for the outdoor spaces at this time of year. Through that decision, regardless of pre-covid contracts, we had hoped that businesses would be reasonable in their approach to working with people who were already faced with such upsetting circumstances. All other vendors we had contracted with for our original date were flexible and accommodating in providing refunds, particularly if they could not offer us future options that met the expectations we had originally agreed upo... Read moren. It is disappointing to be in the scenario in which the Old Mill refuses a refund of our original deposits. With the state just going green on our original wedding day, we would have had no access to fittings for our wedding day attire, vendors who were unsure of their ability to offer their continued services based on the circumstances, and many other services that we had planned to use to create the day we had always dreamed of. Regardless of their willingness to offer virtual meetings, a wedding takes much more than just the assistance of the venue to pull off. We are all managing unprecedented circumstances, things not covered by contracts and in an emotionally driven industry; to selectively make changes to parts of the contract to accommodate rescheduling, but not have the willingness to refund a deposit is representative to us of a business’s core values. While we all are struggling financially and experiencing hardship like never before, this is an unfortunate stance to take and we caution others planning to hold their event at the Old Mill for their future big day until things return to “normal.” Given the significant increase in numbers over the week since going green, we are, ultimately, glad with the decision we made to protect our loved ones.

Where to even start?!? The Old Mill and Conner Catering are spectacular. From the moment we booked to the day of the wedding, Donald, Taylor and the rest of the team went above and beyond for us. For our wedding, we requested a family style dinner. Working hand in hand with Donald and his team, we created a stellar menu for our 150+ guests. Their execution and thoroughness were second to none. Our guests enjoyed every bite of food, from start to finish. They are still talking about how delicious everything was! The waitstaff were attentive, polite and so friendly! The Old Mill served as the absolute perfect backdrop for our special day with Conner Catering. We simply cannot recommend it enough!

Most beautiful wedding venue in Pennsylvania, possibly in the United States!

We cannot say enough about the Conners and this venue. From the very first moment we knew we were in good hands. They were top notch, yet affordable. High standards, but flexible with letting us change things up and bring in our little touches. The wait staff and vendors were cherished by our guests- they were professional, trustworthy and good-hearted people. It was clear how happy they were for us. Our entire event turn-keyed around what and who Don Conner recommended. We call him the David Foster of the southeastern Pennsylvania catering world. He brought gifted artists together for us and arranged the evening like a piece of music. From the first moment we sat down with him he paved the way for a reassuring and enjoyable process. The venue has two equally beautiful outdoor areas and two indoor areas, so even though it rained for our wedding, it didn't feel like we were cheated. This magical place proves the expression that 'good begets good'. The Conners have brought togethe... Read morer something very sweet and rare here in Rose Valley. They make magic happen in this Robin Hood glen tucked away from the world around it. Wishing we could do it all over again!

This venue is gorgeous beyond all belief! Loved my indoor wedding and the cocktail hour outside in the pavilion! Our guests were so impressed with the area and some asked me for their info so they could look into having their wedding here too! Catering was PHENOMENAL!!!

We are in the process of finalizing our booking for the old mill for our 2018 wedding and we've been really happy with our experience so far :) Taylor has been wonderful with responding to our e-mails and answering all of our questions and we feel confident we're in great hands so far! We chose the old mill not only because it is just so gorgeous, but we really liked how conner catering was willing to work with us to design a wedding that was uniquely ours. We're looking forward to our big day and will update!

Everything was wonderful! We got so many compliments. And it was overwhelmingly commented that it was the best wedding food ever!

We can't say enough about don & his staff. Everything about our day (and well before) was perfect. We were so lucky to have found the old mill!

The Old Mill is a beautiful rustic magical venue. My daughters ceremony was in the adjoining meadow surrounded by tall trees and bamboo. The sound of the creek added to the quiet somberness of the meadow. The pavilion and outdoor courtyard accommodated comfortably our guests during appetizers. And the ballroom with the stone fireplace and walls together with the wood ceiling gives off such an elegant and rustic warmth. We added the bistro lights which are extra but completed the warmth of the room. Connor Catering (excusive caterer of the venue) topped the whole evening off with food that was as delicious as the presentation on the plates. The appetizers were amazing! Don was great to work with along with his team. Also our photographer could not get over all the photo opportunities this venue had to offer. A beautiful memory was created that night for my daughter and her husband.

The Old Mill is a hidden gem that can be found in the luscious woods of Rose Valley that simply has a charm to it like no other. I was married there in the summer with the hope of a wedding theme of Celtic-Woodland, and the venue itself looks something out of a fairytale. It is cost-efficient, incredibly beautiful on the inside and out, and is manned by the most talented group of caterers I have ever met. Conner Catering and the team at The Old Mill helped bring my elaborate theme to life and my 200 guests left feeling satisfied, happy, and in wonder at how they had never heard of this place before. As a bride, the Old Mill is incredible, but I also have a unique perspective on the caterers and the venue itself because I am also a wedding photographer. The caterers and their staff treat you like family...sophisticated family...and are prepared to wait on you hand and foot and make sure everything goes the way it should. I am greatly appreciative to Don, Taylor, Jeanne, and the entire C... Read moreonner Team for their incredible hard work and their willingness to put up with one detail-crazy photographer/bride. THANK YOU!

I will be honest, everything about this venue will take your breath away. The entire facility is beautiful for your ceremony and your reception. You can customize parts with your own decor or exclusive contractors for lighting. The lighting package is extremely overpriced and quite frankly they should just leave the lights up all the time. I don’t know who wouldn’t want them. Unfortunately it was not in our budget. However, it did not take away from our experience at all. All of our guests remarked on the beauty of the place. The best part was the ceremony in the bamboo garden and the creek that runs through the property. Although no one was there for our rehearsal, I would choose this venue again. I can’t wait to see the pictures that were taken by the photographer.

I grew up down the street from the Old Mill, and have loved it for years. It is absolutely stunning. The meadow and stream are beautiful any time of the year, and the building, courtyard, and new pavilion addition are all wonderful spaces for anyone to enjoy. Since there is an exclusive caterer, you must consider their costs and quality as well. The exclusive caterer, Conner Catering, who deals with booking the space, all of the set up, tables, linens, catering, etc. provided a great day of result. We had some issues with getting some responses back before we were within a month of our date, like a venue rule change that was our of their control and we were not informed of until only a few days before the wedding. But as soon as we got within a month of our date, I got intimidate calls back to emails, so other questions I had were sorted out quickly. Based on the high number of guests we had, there was little flexibility with table arrangement and style, but they did work with us for ... Read morethe set up we wanted regarding table numbering. The day of staff was great, and food came out promptly, and they catered to all of our guests' dietary restrictions, which was very appreciated by us and our guests. They even brought out a tray of appetizers for me and my husband during cocktail hour while we were taking pictures so we didn't miss out on any of the great food we had picked out. Overall, we loved our day at the Old Mill.

Overall, we absolutely loved our experience with The Old Mill! It's not a cookie cutter place and you won't get a cookie cutter experience either. They won't give you a solid price and there are no packages so you can really do whatever and they try to work with your budget. For everything I wanted I guess it ended up being a bit more expensive than I budgeted for but our wedding ended up being so amazing so I didn't mind and I think it was worth it. Donald was a pleasure to work with and he mainly communicates by text and I liked that so it was a plus for me. The venue is absolutely stunning the only thing that disappointed me is you can't have any live music (using an amp) during the cocktail hour (if you choose to do it outside on the pavilion). We wanted to have a live acoustic guitarist before the ceremony and during the cocktail hour but due to noise constraints it wasn't really working. We still had them play during cocktail hour but they couldn't be too loud and they kind of en... Read moreded up getting lost among all of the voices of cocktail hour. I guess it's the price you pay for getting married in such a natural and quiet place. We got married in the grove and it was gorgeous and we literally had such an amazing perfect day. Thank you to Donald and his crew for making our day so special! Photos that are uploaded are by Renee Nicolo Photography!

Don and the Conner Catering teamed helped make our wedding day absolutely perfect. Throughout the planning process Don listened and understood the vision we wanted and helped steer us in the right direction to make it happen. The day of the wedding, the team at the Old Mill could not have been more accommodating. They were attentive to my husband and I making sure that we had everything we needed or wanted. Our guests raved about the food, and my husband and I have to agree with them. The atmosphere of the Old Mill was just perfect and the Connor Catering team helped make it a welcoming and fun environment to be in. There was not one thing I would have changed about our day!