Find Local Wedding Vendors

Discover and connect with wedding vendors that share your taste and your budget. With trusted reviews, you can rest easy that your wedding day will be as beautiful as you envisioned.

Cakes in Shrewsbury,
(732) 741-3802
Overall Rating
4.7 out of 5
Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • 58 Reviews


    Rachel

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Joely is a busy woman but let me tell you...she knows what she's doing. Our cake tasting was so much fun and both our wedding and groom cake were amazing in look and taste. I couldn't have imagined anything better and her friendly personality was just icing on the cake - haha.

    Carly

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I have to say the cake was the most fun planning and most complimented on the day of our wedding! Our guests could not get over how beautiful the cake was and then how delicious. A pleasure from the first moment to the day of. Thank you! We will be back!

    Sandra

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We absolutely loved our wedding cake! It looked perfect, we received a lot of compliments on the detail, and it tasted absolutely delicious! Thank you so much for adding to our special day!!!

    Tara

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • My venue uses Piece O Cake to provide their wedding cakes and they did a gorgeous job! Our cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! Several people told us that it was the best wedding cake they ever had! If your venue does not provide a cake and you have to choose a bakery on your own, check out Piece O Cake in Shrewsbury, NJ.

    Josie

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Joely, thank you for the beautiful cake. It was absolutely stunning and it tasted just as good as it looked. Efrin & Josie

    Lauren

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Piece O' Cake was an amazing experience from start to finish. The cakes we so beautiful and they were very easy to work with. Joely helped us to customize our cake so that we could afford the cake of our dreams. The cake was a huge hit at our wedding. It was beautiful and scrumptous! A must use!!!!

    ashley

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Our venue, Eagle Ridge Golf Club, works with Piece O' Cake. Our cake was delicious! We received many compliments on how good it was, and we loved it ourselves! I know we're supposed to save the top tier, but once they sent it home with us, we ate it ourselves while it was still fresh! They really accommodated our requests (chocolate cake with key lime filling and vanilla buttercream icing) and the cake was decorated beautifully and simply with trailing sugar pearls. LOVED IT!!!

    jennifer

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Our location for our wedding used Piece O"cake to supply the cake. I contacted them (Joely specifically) and she was absolutely fabuolous. They provided us with samples and created a cake for that was wonderful. We asked for a few minor changes and Joely made us a spectacular cake. All of our guests enjoyed the cake so much they gave it all out (some people wanted seconds)! However, Piece O'Cake will make you an anniversary cake so you have a fresh cake to enjoy on your first anniversary. I can't say enough about Piece O'Cake and Joely....I would highly recommend their services to everyone!!

    Jenny

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Our caterer recommended Piece O' Cake to do our cake. We were so pleased that we chose them to do our cake. I have never heard such raves at a wedding about the look and the taste of the cake. Thank you Piece O' Cake! You made our day even better then expected.

    Lee

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • They were AWESOME!!! Great selections and generous samples! First class!!!

    Brooke

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • the cake was absolutely delicious and gorgeous. Everyone truly enjoyed!

    Erica

    reviews
    4.5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Although the actual cake designer is not always at the shop she usually gets back to you pretty quickly through e-mail. It was a no fuss process. We were able to get a beautiful and delicious cake for a great cost. We weren't looking for anything over the top (although it seems like she does that as well) and she was able to help us immediately. The cake was delicious!!! I never am impressed by wedding cakes but this one was great! She also offered to make us a fresh cake for our anniversary which was a nice plus! Very laid back shop which was just my style!

    Tara

    reviews
    4.8 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I had Joely make my wedding cake and it was beautiful and delicious. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with cannoli and chocolate mousse filling iced in a very smooth buttercream. It was so smooth my husband said that it looked fake. The gumpaste flowers were turquoise and while they were bluer than the aqua swatch I gave her it wasnt that big of a deal. Also, the icing around the base of the layers was supposed to be aqua but it was white. The pearlized fondant swag was lovely. The cake tasted great. I had two slices at the reception. I cant wait to order another cake from Piece O Cake in the future. The service and responsiveness was also good. Joely responded to my emails in a very timely manner. The cost was a little expensive but I think its about average for wedding cakes. Its definitely alot cheaper than Carlos Bakery or Palermos and the cake tasted way better than Palermos. Overall I was very satisfied.

    Alexandra

    reviews
    4.6 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • The perfect wedding cake!! Unlike so many other wedding cakes, this was delicious and uniquely flavored.

    Meghan

    reviews
    2.4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • The taste of the cake was wonderful, they have beautiful designs and were really helpful when I wanted to suprise my groom with a grooms cake. However, they sent me the the wrong wedding cake, it was the same flavor but wrong design. I wasn't really good with confrontation and called to inform them that they sent me the wrong cake and they apologized but never offered to cover for their mistake. It didn't ruin my day but it was disappointing.

    responded with the following comments.

    When I spoke with Meghan I was so embarrased of the mistake I had made. I offered to make her a tiered cake for her anniversary or for any other special occasion that she would need a cake for. Again I profusely appologized and asked if my offer was acceptable. Until I read this review I was under the impression we were ok. I am very sorry and wish she had let me know what she wanted. My offer does still stand if she would like.

    Find Amazing Vendors
    render_sticky_availability_button