Find Local Wedding Vendors

Discover and connect with wedding vendors that share your taste and your budget. With trusted reviews, you can rest easy that your wedding day will be as beautiful as you envisioned.

Cakes in East Haven, CT,
(203) 469-1817
Overall Rating
4.9 out of 5
Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • 54 Reviews


    Kristina Bruce

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I had an idea in mind of what I wanted, which changed when I found out they don't do fondant cakes. But they were still able to do the colors I wanted, the ombre design, and the most delicious cake! We had one layer of chocolate cake and one layer of confetti cake (which is my absolute favorite). It was so personalized and no fondant meant everyone got to enjoy every last bit of cake on their plate! This bakery is part of wedding traditions in my family and they were so flexible, affordable, and easy to work with.

    Carolyn

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Petonito's was FANTASTIC!! We booked Petonito's as part of a package with our venue and it was so nice having a vendor that was so familiar with our venue. Our cake was made exactly how we had envisioned and the staff was so kind (they gave us complimentary cookies when we booked!). We had two different flavors in our cake and our guests really loved both! Additionally, we had bought two birthday cakes because we had a couple of birthdays at our wedding and those were also beautiful and special. The cakes were great and the service was attentive; I would highly recommend Petonito's!

    Cait

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Upon seeing our wedding cake for the first time, I was incredibly pleased to see how beautiful it looked. From the purple ribbon wrapped around the bottom layers to the white roses scattered throughout, it was stunning. Once we opened up the cake, the funfetti cake and strawberry filling took it over the top! Thank you for a delicious addition to our wedding day!

    Ruoxi

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We held our wedding at Amarante's Sea Cliff. The package there includes a wedding cake from Petonito's Pastry Shop. So we went to Petonito's Pastry Shop to pick a flavor. Mark was very nice and helpful. He let us try five different flavors which were actually all very impressive. After quite a discussion, we narrowed down to two flavors and Mark offered to make the two flavors separately into the three tiers of the cake. This was very helpful because our guests could choose the one that they prefer. Our guests enjoyed the cake very much! The design of the cake was also wonderful! It looks very elegant in our photos.

    Samantha

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Our cake was beautiful - the "vision" we had for our wedding cake was interpreted perfectly. We barely ate any because we were so busy dancing, but our guests raved about how delicious it was! We will, for sure, be ordering cakes for our "life events" in the future. Thanks for making our dream cake!

    Elena

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • From the minute we met Mark we knew Petonito's was our decision. We loved how traditional he was & how it is a family owned business. It truly felt like he cared about every person that came in his pastry shop. He let us taste several cakes and fillings. Let me tell you, it was hard to choose! Mark and Adrianna made the process so easy & ensured us everything would look beautiful. LET ME TELL YOU, they were right! Not only was the cake gorgeous, we got endless compliments on how delicious our cake was (White cake with strawberry mouse filling for those wondering). We were able to rent out their cake stand, and it was definitely one of our best decisions. The cake was prettier than I could have ever dreamed. One of my best vendor choices! Thank you Petonito's for your beautiful and delicious work. I would highly recommend.

    Patricia

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We loved our cake! it was exactly what we asked for and was so great we might not be able to freeze the top!

    Danielle&Rob

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We had the pleasure of working with Mark, and the whole experience was absolutely perfect! He was open to customizing our cake, even though it was included with our reception venue. It was absolutely stunning, and tasted even more delicious!

    Linda

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Cake was beautiful and tasted delicious! I had real flowers added to the cake, cascading down and it was just as I imagined it. The only thing I wanted to change was to only have dots for design ( no swirls). I called 3 days before my wedding to change it but it turned out my cake had already been made and decorated. So just know exactly what you want or call at least a week in advance to make any changes.

    User3829220

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Our cake was PERFECT. Draped roses and a cake design... Exactly what we wanted ... beautiful. It tasted AMAZING.

    User3276794

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Petonito's made mine and my husband's wedding cake. It looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Before going for our initial tasting, we went to a different cake company and had a very poor experience with them. After leaving this company, we decided to take a chance and show up at Petonito's unannounced expecting to be told we would need to make an appointment. To our surprise, they sat down with us right away and gave us a cake tasting! Everything was delicious and we booked with them right away. The entire staff was so friendly and the cake came out perfect!

    User5619322

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We got our fill of amazing cakes during the tasting and the wedding cake was beautiful, elegant, and absolutely perfect

    Jennifer

    reviews
    4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Delicious cake and it looked beautiful on our table!

    Jacqueline

    reviews
    3.8 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • My fiance and I had our engagement cake done by Petonito's. Mark is extremely friendly and the cake looked SO BEAUTIFUL, but unfortunately the cake did not taste good at all. We were all very disappointed. =(

    Jessica

    reviews
    4.7 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We were very happy with our wedding cake from Petonito's. It came out gorgeously, and even though I only had one bite on our wedding day, I had some a few days later and it still tasted great. I'm looking forward to having some more cake on our one year anniversary!
    1 2 3 4

    Find Amazing Vendors
    render_sticky_availability_button