Melissa Mumma
reviews
| Quality of Service: |  |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
(941) 778-3909
(941) 778-3909
Overall Rating
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
56 Reviews
Melissa Mumma
reviews
Sherry Hendrickson
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
She was amazing. Took my vision and brought it to life!!
Toni
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
This cake shop is the best. I live in Colorado but the wedding was in Florida. i read the reviews and viewed the web site pictures. Loved the designs on the cakes. my wedding was small so i only needed a two tier cake but i wanted it to look
very special. I emailed the shop several times on ideas, and using combination of several cakes.
The final cake as just perfect and oh my goodness the taste was out of this world. Several local people asked where
i got it.
i would only use this shop if i lived in town!!!
User6321849
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
They did a wonderful job with our cake! We were able to organize everything through email and it was very convenient, great pricing, and they did exactly what we hoped for!
Phoebe
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
We heard about Matt and Dom from a friend of ours and we were so happy we chose them to make our cake!
After our initial tasting, we knew we didn't need to go anywhere else. Matt and Dom provided an amazing selection and each cake we tried was absolutely delicious.
In addition to our wedding cake, we also ordered a groom's cake with them. Both cakes were exactly how I had envisioned and exactly what I had hoped for.
I am so happy that I chose to work with Matt and Dom and I highly recommend them to anyone looking to have a beautiful and incredibly tasting cake.
Alaina
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
Matt and Dom's came highly recommended by our event coordinator at Pier 22. We contacted them for a tasting and were so impressed we didn't bother looking any further. The cake was delicious and they have so many options available. I think what really pushed me over the edge was that they do not make their cakes ahead of time and freeze them. Every cake these brothers make is made fresh within 2-3 days of the event.
Ashley
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
Matt & Dom made us a delicious wedding cake!! I communicated with them only through e-mail since I was planning a destination wedding & they were always professional & quick to respond. I looked into other bakeries where I was quoted DOUBLE for the same size cake. We had a cookies & cream cake..my guests & my husband & myself all loved it. They delivered on time & the cake itself was absolutely beautiful.
Jennifer
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
I couldn't have asked for a more PERFECT wedding cake! I had a destination wedding and actually stumbled upon this quaint little bakery shop and I couldn't have been more pleased. The cakes they make are so fresh and so elegant! Matt and Dom are super easy to work with and I've never tasted a more delicious cake! My wedding cake was beautiful and exactly what I had hoped for!
User4153252
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
We ordered our wedding cake from Matt and Dom's after tasting their cake at a bridal show. Our cake was beautiful! It was exactly what we asked for. It tasted absolutely amazing too! We could not have been happier. Their cakes are in a completely different category from every other bakery we considered.
Carmen
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
Our wedding cake was spectacular & delicious thank you Matt for all your help & for our beautiful cake! Also thankyou for the delicious strawberries. I would recommend you guys to my Florida family anytime. Our cake pictures are out great no one know the cake was part fake. You guys are fantastic"
Jennifer
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
Absolutely gorgeous and delicious cakes!! Matt even helped plan to save us money!!
Highly recommended! !! A++++++++++
debbie
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
Wonderful job on our cake and cupcakes for our 1/24/15 wedding at The Beachhouse Restaurant on Anna Maria Island. They delivered the cake on time and with all of it's associated parts! I loved it and so did the guests at our wedding! The cake was flavorful and moist, the frosting was not too sweet and perfectly thick/rigid for the cupcakes (to hold the shell ornaments) and smooth marzipan for the cake topper. Great service, very professional, easy to work with (somewhat of a rush), great designs to chose from and customize! WONDERFUL, WONDERFUL job! Can't say enough!
Liz
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
They were great! I searched pics of cakes and they made the perfect version of what I was looking for. They were flexible with the flavors and helped my husband with the groom's cake. Espresso Chocolate Chip--WOW. The grooms cake was customized to look like my husband's hockey jersey and what a job they did! Beautiful and delicious! We had so many people rave about it! Perfect!
Lauren
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: |  |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
The cake was delicious!
We went simple with a marble cake with buttercream and everyone loved it.
Working with Matt and Dom was great. I wasn't able to make the cake tasting so they sent my husband home with samples for me to try which was so nice.
They took the photo I sent them and made our cake look exactly as I wanted and used the flower that my florist delivered to them.
I felt that it was a little expensive, and sometimes it took a while to get a response for my emails, but honestly the quality of the cake really is worth the price.
Maggie
reviews
| Quality of Service: | |
| Responsiveness: | |
| Professionalism: | |
| Value for Cost: | |
| Flexibility: | |
I cannot begin to say how happy I was with my wedding cake. Matt knew exactly what I wanted from the first meeting and my vision came to life on my wedding day. I had mentioned that I wanted an orange ombre cake with the inside cake to be orange ombre as well. When I got to the consultation, Matt had actually created the orange ombre cake for us to taste! He went above and beyond and the cake on our wedding day was gorgeous. It tasted so good that most of our guests ate more than one slice. I can't wait to eat it again on our one year anniversary :) Thank you Matt & Dom's!
responded with the following comments.
Thank you so much for the amazing review! I'm so glad you enjoyed it! Congratulations to you and we can't wait to see you on your next visit to the area!