Find Local Wedding Vendors

Discover and connect with wedding vendors that share your taste and your budget. With trusted reviews, you can rest easy that your wedding day will be as beautiful as you envisioned.

Catering in Sun Prairie, WI,

Market Street Diner & Carl’s Cakes

110 Market Street
Sun Prairie, WI, WI
Services: Catering | Login to save vendor
(608) 825-3377
Overall Rating
4.8 out of 5
Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • 31 Reviews


    Ashley

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We love Market Street Diner and all of their desserts, so Carl's Cakes was an obvious cake choice for us. Our wedding cake was the BEST! I hyped it up to our family and friends and it did not disappoint. They commented about how great it was afterward.

    Shontae

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Chef Josie did an excellent job with our cake! We went their classic vanilla, raspberry purée, with vanilla buttercream, it was to die for! All of our guests raves about how good it was, we got tons of “this is best wedding cake” compliments, and trust me our people are HONEST. We kept the design simple, but it still had wow factor. I wouldn’t go to anyone else for cake about such a great experience!

    Louis

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • The new catering manager provided some fresh ideas to some of the things were had discussed with the previous manager. It was a pleasure working with her.

    Chelly

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • When planning our Madison wedding, we had many recommendations from family and friends. When it came to cake, the only recommendation we received (from multiple people) was Carl’s Cakes. About a year before our wedding, we had breakfast at the Market Street Diner on a morning when Carl was working and didn’t happen to be overly busy. We told him we were interested in having him bake our cake and he provided us with an unscheduled tasting on the spot, during which he also showed us photos of cake designs and explained his process. Needless to say, we went with Carl’s Cakes and they didn’t let us down! Our mothers also ordered a groom’s cake from Carl decorated with the groom’s favorite hobbies for the rehearsal dinner.

    Meghan

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Carl's Cakes are AMAZING! They were excellent to work with, the cup cakes were a hit!

    Mikaela

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • What can we say – when we were shopping around for prices, Carl’s Cakes was both higher rated and lower cost than the other options! Carl is a great guy, really easy to work with, and definitely a master of his profession. The cake flavors themselves are very delicious. We picked chocolate raspberry and apricot hazelnut, and got a lot of compliments from our guests on both flavors. The cake was just beautiful, and we were really pleased with our overall experience with Carl’s Cakes!

    Abigail

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Carl was super friendly and great to work with. The cake tasted amazing - we went with lemon and raspberry and a layer of chocolate and raspberry. Sooooo delicious and very moist. Everything went without a single hitch.

    Leah

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful! We had a 4 tiered cake a simple white frosting. It was decorated with a blue ribbon that I had embellished with sparkles. Our cake topper was an elegant music symbol to match the ribbon and it was all put together perfectly! I wish I had a picture to share - we got so many compliments! And it was also delicious! In fact, we only had 1 extra slice at the end of the evening and our cake was plenty big enough for our number of guests! Our cake was also delivered about 35 miles outside of the Madison area and Carl was so fun to work with. I highly recommend Carl's Cakes!

    User5258576

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Carl's Cakes are the BEST. We had a lot of delicious options and ended up going with the vanilla raspberry and chocolate raspberry. It is a delicious cake that leaves a very clean (non-filmy) feeling in your mouth. The cake was beautiful, delivery went off without a hitch, and Carl is an absolute pleasure to work with!

    Megan

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Carl's cakes did our wedding cake and it was amazing! Not only did it taste great but looked great too :) Couldn't have been happier!

    Kimberly

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Great tasting cake and upfront and clear about pricing. Cake turned out exactly how I wanted it. Responsive to email.

    Jade

    reviews
    4.2 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Cake: Everything with our cake was great! Josie was great to work with. She worked with us on the design and flavors, and the end result looked beautiful. No issues at all and I heard it was delicious (I only had time to eat a bite during the cake cutting, and we somehow didn't get our leftover cake to keep). Catering: Everything went smoothly day of. Jaime, the events manager, was friendly and organized. She was willing to work with us and was quick to respond to emails. She and the catering operations manager helped set up rentals through Event Essentials (for tables, high chairs, etc.) This was very helpful, although it was a little pushy at times (maybe they get a commission for setting up rentals?). We got a discount for renting through them this way. We had a lot of back and forth about the alcohol amounts needed for the reception but Jaime worked with us to compromise on the amounts needed. The food tasted amazing. Everyone who got food had compliments for it; however, I was... Read more

    Brittney

    reviews
    4.4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • The cake is always superb, and working with Carl’s during the wedding planning process was so, SO easy. The staff are very relaxed, helpful, reliable, and do an excellent job with decoration.

    Michelle

    reviews
    4.4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We used Carl's Cake for our daughters wedding and the cake was beautiful and delicious!

    Princess

    reviews
    3.8 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • We wanted a simple cake that complemented our cake topper. Carl designed a simple yet elegant 3-tier cake. We loved the flavor options. The cake was beautiful.
    1 2 3

    Find Amazing Vendors
    render_sticky_availability_button