Find Local Wedding Vendors

Discover and connect with wedding vendors that share your taste and your budget. With trusted reviews, you can rest easy that your wedding day will be as beautiful as you envisioned.

Cakes in New York, New York,
(212) 234-2344
Overall Rating
4.7 out of 5
Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • 26 Reviews


    Kisha

    reviews
    4.9 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Absolutely delicious cakes, beautiful decorations. Phone may ring and you may wait a few minutes for an order taker, it is well worth it. Any design, flavor and an absolute dream come true.

    Kahlia

    reviews
    4.9 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I have ordered several baby shower and birthday cakes and they are always raved about! They have great cupcake too!

    Melissa

    reviews
    4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • JoAnn and her staff were great. They worked very well with what kind of cake and design my husband and I wanted. The cake came out beautiful and looked beautiful. Plus, it was delicious and everyone enjoyed it! I would definitely recommend their services to other people.

    Dianne

    reviews
    4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • They should feel comfortable booking the venue. The cake will be delicious.

    Miranda

    reviews
    4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • The cake here has always been delicious, and our wedding cake followed suit! Our guests were so happy with how good the cake tasted, and how unique the pineapple/coconut combo was.

    User7515192

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • So delicious! The best red velvet in harlem!!

    Aaron

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I think the best advice is to come with any ideas or details that you might want in your cake. Bring color swatches, pictures, etc. MakeMyCake also has a great book of cakes they've created for their clients in the past that you can draw ideas from.

    Jessica

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • One of my favorite bakeries in NYC, and my favorite chocolate cake. Kind, attentive, and flexible.

    Peter

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Didn't use them for a wedding. They did my birthday cake, and it was fabulous! It was ready for pickup exactly when it was supposed to be. Just the perfect cake -- looked great, tasted great. Mighty sweet. Everybody loved it, and because I ordered right I had a lot left to eat for a couple of days as a reminder of a great party. Make My Cake did my son's birthday cakes from the age of 2 to about 18, and now they've made one for my 70th. They make a wonderful occasion cake, and it's also an excellent place to drop by for a slice of something good,

    Jeanine

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • OMG!! What an amazing cake you did for us!!!

    responded with the following comments.

    Thank you very much for your kind review! We look forward to making your cake for your next special occasion.

    Brandi

    reviews
    5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • There's not much to say about my process with MMC - my now husband and I did a cake tasting, secured the date, delivery and the head baker/owner helped me pick out a beautiful cake topper! It was a pleasure picking Make My Cake!

    T

    reviews
    4.4 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Make My Cake is a clean and professional atmosphere to be in. I just wish there was some kind of Reward program.

    Lisa

    reviews
    4.8 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I have had cakes from” Make My Cake” on a number of occasions from parties that I have attended and felt early on in the planning process that I definitely wanted to use them for my wedding cake. Every piece of my wedding cake from the frosting to the filling to the decor was perfectly fresh and delicious. In addition, I loved working with the owner Ms. Joann on the colors design etc. I was offered a wide variety of fillings, and designs with a lovely look book for me to gain ideas and Ms. Joann was also very receptive to the photo examples that I brought along at the cake consultation. We had one minor “hiccup” as the delivery guy forgot the cake topper on the wedding day that I had for my cake however “ Make my cake” acknowledged the issue and since the décor of the cake was so beautiful and the taste exceptional no one really noticed the missing topper it still ended up being a lovely cake. Established experts in baked goods and a must visit in Harlem NY! I highly r... Read more

    Fedlene

    reviews
    4.5 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • I order cakes from Make My Cake all the time so when it came time for my wedding cake, I knew where I was going. The cake was absolutely stunning. Everything I had dreamed for. Taste was more important than anything and they delivered. I had a 4 tier cake with red velvet, butter cake with pineapple and caramel fillings. Everyone loved the cake!

    Diana

    reviews
    4.6 out of 5
    Quality of Service:
  • Responsiveness:
  • Professionalism:
  • Value for Cost:
  • Flexibility:
  • Make My Cake made an AMAZING cake for my wedding. It was beautiful, delicious (everyone ate their slice), and very affordable! They were easy to work with and offered suggestions to stay within my budget. I would recommend using Make My Cake for any event or wedding!!

    Find Amazing Vendors
    render_sticky_availability_button